Archived posting to the Leica Users Group, 2008/01/05
[Author Prev] [Author Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Author Index] [Topic Index] [Home] [Search]May I agree with you all? Indeed, your points of view can be reconciled in a way, after all. For me http://contest.leica-users.org/main.php/v/0712/McfR-1_5.jpg.html has a Diane Arbus tinge to it that made me like it at once, together with http://contest.leica-users.org/main.php/v/0712/caregiver.jpg.html I rate them both as wonderful documentary photographs IMHO. I also liked http://contest.leica-users.org/main.php/v/0712/91038-04A.jpg.html for its atmosphere (good old times wrote Luis, rightly so) and http://contest.leica-users.org/main.php/v/0712/L1000362.jpg.html for the intensity conveyed by these wonderful hands and the tweed cap Just my pinch of salt. thanks Steve for bringing out the comments issue on this so interesting series. and to you Brian for picking it up. phx G Hopkinson wrote: >I am really surprised by these comments. That is a good lesson on how our >perceptions/impressions can differ. No doubt they will >stimulate a discussion. That can only be good. >For me, while I understand Brian's comments on tone and the background >elements, I don't see it that way. It is an unmanipulated >photograph of a real situation. The light was there and the clutter was >there. It makes a moving scene for me. I don't at all see >the woman as uncaring. Really, though a very emotive and personal >photograph. >Regards >Geoff > >-----Original Message----- >Subject: Re: [Leica] December 2007 LUG Photo Contest results > > >On Jan 5, 2008, at 1:17 PM, Brian Reid wrote: > > > >>>Somehow though the nature of "contest" dampens comment and >>>discussion of entries, both before and after results are announced. >>> >>> >>OK, I'll bite. >> >>About this picture, which took second prize: >> >>http://contest.leica-users.org/main.php/v/0712/McfR-1_5.jpg.html >> >>I find it to be muddy and diffuse. The subject matter is indeed >>compelling, but the photograph just doesn't grab me. The patient's >>skin tones are almost the same color as the wall behind him, and the >>clutter distracts me. >> >> > > >funny you mention it Brian... > >actually, this one doesn't grab me at all... > >compelling subject matter, yes... > >but the subjective response is everything...and for me goes beyond the skin >tones... > >I think that the technique is fine, but certainly secondary. > >an apology to Bob in advance, but Caring ?....I don't think so... > >my wife and I looked at all the images together, in quite a bit of detail. > >Of course, we had our favorites and not so..... > >this one we unceremoniously subtitled... > > >"hey Rex ...are you dead yet ? > > >:-( > >Steve > > > >>Some of the judges are subscribed to the LUG; some are not. If you are >>a judge and you are tempted to reply to my comment please take care >>not to reveal yourself. >> >>Brian Reid >> >> >> >>_______________________________________________ >>Leica Users Group. >>See http://leica-users.org/mailman/listinfo/lug for more information >> >> > > >_______________________________________________ >Leica Users Group. >See http://leica-users.org/mailman/listinfo/lug for more information > > > >_______________________________________________ >Leica Users Group. >See http://leica-users.org/mailman/listinfo/lug for more information > > >