[Leica] PAW - Toronto on the Horizon

[tedgrant at shaw.ca (Ted Grant)]

Philippe Orlent offered:
Subject: Re: [Leica] PAW - Toronto on the Horizon


> Both suggested crops are better.
> Ted's crop is a very classic composition and a effective one, too,  but 
> personnally I prefer Daniel's version. A bold cut in half making  it into 
> a beautiful panoramic shot.
> With a bit of color work (pushing the greens and blues -a delicate  job) 
> it could become very striking indeed.<<<

Sorry Philippe,
But the scene cut in half version makes the water too small and looks like 
it was tacked on the bottom.

I don't want to get into a "cropping match" but there is a comfort zone of 
looking at the scene. If I had to take the chopped water version offered as 
the only option I'd rather go for the original photo!

Because the water is like a strip tacked on the bottom when the scene is cut 
in half.

ted

Hugh Thompson showed:
>> Like many other's I say right now that I will put up a new image  every 
>> week ...... that's what I say right now:
>>>> first PAW ...... Toronto on the horizon:
>>>>> http://gallery.leica-users.org/v/Hugh+Thompson/PAW/L1020327.jpg.html