Re: [Leica] Mythology v Reality - A Call For A Thoughtful Discussion

[drbledsoe <drbledsoe@yahoo.com>]

I think you answered your own question (even though I'm not completely
certain just what it was).  While many photographers on this list (as
you note) could make great photos regardless of the equipment they
use, they are also not limited in that pursuit by inferior optical or
mechanical quality.  

Perhaps the razor sharpness, brilliance, contrast, freedom from flare,
etc. of many of the current Leica lenses are not necessary to a superb
photograph.  But what about that one in a million shot where just one
of those attributes is not just necessary, it is critical?  In other
words, a "decisive moment" in photography is, in my opinion, a
decisive moment for many reasons.  I see it as a coalescence of many
things.  Any one of which if missing could render the result little
more than just another photograph. 

In terms of the mechanical aspects, well Tina provided a wonderful
explanation not to mention her insight on the optical characteristics
of Leica.  But for me, a so-so photographer with goofy ambitions, well
I like the feeling Leica gives me.  A feeling that the only thing
holding me back from being a great photographer are my own
inabilities, not those of my Leica equipment.  Pretty much exactly as
the feeling I got reading your description of why you like the Martin
D-35.

Then again, this has all been hashed out a gazillion times before.  I
doubt there are any out there who will agree that Leica equipment will
magically transform a poor photographer into a great photographer.  We
all know it is the person behind the viewfinder. Whatshisname from
France, the socialist guy, used to point that out all the time here. 
He seemed to relish baiting the group into frenzied chatter through
his criticism for all who maintained a bourgeois infatuation with the
latest Leica equipment.

As always, it keeps thing fun though.
Is it rolling Bob?

Best, Don


 

_________________________________________________________
DO YOU YAHOO!?
Get your free @yahoo.com address at http://mail.yahoo.com