Archived posting to the Leica Users Group, 2000/11/26

[Author Prev] [Author Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Author Index] [Topic Index] [Home] [Search]

Subject: [Leica] Age and style
From: imx <imxputs@knoware.nl>
Date: Sun, 26 Nov 2000 17:38:38 +0100

Robert asked:

> Erwin wrote
>>>>>> 
> From a birds eye perspective (having studied books and magazine-articles
> from 1870 till today) ...
> <<<<<
> 
> Erwin, I thought _I_ was the oldest Lugger! How old were you when you
> started this research?

My English may not be good enough, but I was under the impression that
"..articles from 1870" means a  range, that is articles dating from 1870 and
that "since 1870" indicates a start date.
Semantics is interesting: does the "from 1870" refer to the date of the
articles or to the date that the study started?
But to avoid any confusion: my birthdate is in the 20th century.

On my style of posting. I hate getting posts that are pages long just
because the person copies and recopies the whole thread. That is why I
delete most of the text I am referring to: to save bandwidth and get to the
point quickly. Secondly: you can be argumentative in your approach and use
the Lug as a forum to discuss whatever topic.

I try to be explanatory and present what I have to say on a topic, either on
my own or triggered by some post, as a mini-article.
 
Some may find this pedantic and insulting to the opinions of others. I
wonder why it is more appropriate and less insulting if a post is designated
as "bullshit" or when you try to explain your own views and respect other
views by letting them stand as they are and presenting a second opinion.

I prefer my approach: it is indeed more explanatory than argumentative: I
hate mudslinging: presidential candidates are better in this game than I am.
I live in a world where you can present several views, compare them on their
merits, even have heated arguments and continue to drink wine and enjoy each
others company. But then we are discussing content, and do not need rude
language to try to become the better of your discussion partners. I will not
engage in any direct discussion with people whose rudeness is part of the
debating style. 
In conclusion: I find the proper Lug etiquette difficult to fathom.

Erwin

Replies: Reply from "A.H.SCHMIDT" <horsts@primus.com.au> ([Leica] Bandwith)
Reply from john <bosjohn@mediaone.net> (Re: [Leica] Age and style)