Archived posting to the Leica Users Group, 2002/05/31

[Author Prev] [Author Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Author Index] [Topic Index] [Home] [Search]

Subject: [Leica] Leica, medium format, and good enough
From: "Don Dory" <dorysrus@mindspring.com>
Date: Fri, 31 May 2002 21:26:04 -0400

There has been a recent thread about Leica quality and medium format at
sizes to 11X14.  Its not that medium format doesn't have the potential for
finer detail than Leica, it's how much trouble you have to go to make a
difference and whether it's worth the effort for the project at hand.

Yes, at middle apertures,(exception granted to certain 100mm or so F2 Zeiss
lenses) using a tripod or studio lights you will get better detail with
medium format.  Do the same with a 90 APO on E100SW and the differences will
be small, very small.  Now, take that 6X7 out and do street photography or
macro in the field and compare the results with what you can do with an M6
or R8 and comparable lenses.  Let's all think about Tina in some abode in
Honduras setting up the tripod for the extra detail: hold still for about 10
seconds while the shutter is open! .  Obviously, if you are doing catalogue
work in the studio you are using something with swings and tilts with a
digital back

Put another way, this is almost the same debate that started in the 30's and
continued to the early 60's as photography moved from 8X10 and 4X5 to 120 in
Rollie's and 35mm in Leica's, Contax's, and later Nikons.  As lenses and
films improved most work moved to the next smaller format.  Even landscape
calendar work is moving into medium format and some 35mm.

Last, all of this is soon moot as digital takes over more and more work.
With better capture devices and clever software interpolating what should be
there the images will snap with fine detail.  Think about Adobe's healing
brush algorithms in a digital camera to create texture from small samples.

In summary, my point is that for most uses, what good technique can wring
out of top notch 35mm(digital) will satisfy most uses in nature, journalism,
macro, street, documentation, fashion, advertising, and now wedding.  Uses
that require tremendous sizes, billboards, outdoor, vain art directors,
catalogue, and calendar work , and artists will still go to medium and large
format capture.

Just trying to get back to photography :)

Don
dorysrus@mindspring.com



- --
To unsubscribe, see http://mejac.palo-alto.ca.us/leica-users/unsub.html

Replies: Reply from Christer Almqvist <chris@almqvist.net> (Re: [Leica] Leica, medium format, and good enough)
Reply from D Khong <dkhong@pacific.net.sg> (Re: [Leica] OT: Rolleiflex FX)
Reply from Jeffery Smith <jls@runbox.com> (Re: [Leica] OT: Rolleiflex FX)