Archived posting to the Leica Users Group, 2001/02/19

[Author Prev] [Author Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Author Index] [Topic Index] [Home] [Search]

Subject: [Leica] Stalking the concert hall
From: Peter Klein <pklein@2alpha.net>
Date: Mon, 19 Feb 2001 21:14:14 -0800

I wrote:
>See my next post for an experience where only a Leica would do.

OK, here goes.

Sunday afternoon, I attended a chamber music concert given by an all-female 
ensemble  consisting of piano, clarinet, and bassoon.  The guest artist was 
a cellist who is a dear friend.  They played some delightful 20th-Century 
wind music, plus an over-the-top Tango for Cello and piano, and the Brahms 
Clarinet Trio.  I decided to see if I could get any decent shots of the 
performance.

Equipment:  M4-P, Luna Pro Digital, 35/2 Summicron (pre-ASPH), and "Blunt 
Instrument," my 85/1.9 Cannon, er, Canon (no, it's not a Summicron but it 
cost 1/4 as much!).  Lens hoods for both.  One fanny pack to sneak said 
gear into the hall.

The stage lights were on before the perforemers entered, so I stuck my 
meter into the illuminated area and took a couple of incident 
readings.  Then I sat down, listened, and did my thing.  I shot half a roll 
of HP-5.

The Leica's shutter was perfect for the occasion.  I only shot during 
mezzo-forte passages or louder, and nobody noticed a thing but my wife and 
maybe the guy behind me.  I think I got a few good shots.  A person taking 
tickets later saw my camera and asked if I was taking pictures.  She hadn't 
heard a thing, and couldn't believe that I could do it without flash.

One major challenge:  Often the best expressions and suspension of motion 
happen on upbeats, which are often quiet, so I wouldn't shoot then.  I did 
not know beforehand where the performers would be sitting, so I couldn't 
choose a seat that would minimize the obstacles of a microphone and music 
stands.  I tried to turn this to an advantage in one shot, where all you 
can see is the cellist's eyes and bow protruding from behind the music 
stand.  I hope that one comes out well.

My biggest frustration, though, was the blasted rangefinder flare.  There 
were a couple of floor lamps on stage to light the music, and they flared 
out the RF.  I know I missed several good shots because I wasn't sure of 
the focus with all that flare, and hesitated too long.  I did a lot of 
stage photography with my dearly departed M2 back in the 70s, and I never 
had this problem.

Back home, I played around with black tape and masking tape on the 
frameline illumination window, and couldn't find any perfect solution.  The 
only way to eliminate the flare was to cover the window completely with 
black tape, and then there are no framelines.  I'm not giving up--perhaps a 
colored gel will help enough, or a polarizing material,  or that stick-on 
thing from the guy in Switzerland.

The flare had me longing for a Bessa R viewfinder.  Just the 
viewfinder.  Not the camera, which would have been far to noisy, and 
couldn't focus an 85/1.9 accurately enough.  But it's amazing to me that 
Leica, the supposed king of quality, would for nearly 20 years produce a 
$2000 camera with such a glaring (literally!) flaw.   Especially since 
Cosina managed to outdo them in a camera costing 1/3 the price!  Especially 
since Leicas are often used for existing light, where light sources are 
often in or near the frame.

Still, only a Leica would do.  The Bessa or the Hexar RF would be too 
noisy.  The old leaf-shutter Hexar doesn't have an 85 or 90mm f/2.  Even a 
quiet SLR like my Olympus OM-2 would have been too noisy.  Next time, I 
think I'll take my IIIf to a concert and see if the lack of flare and more 
magnified RF makes up for the separate viewfinder issue.

The film is at the lab.  I'll try to post something in the near future.  At 
this point all I can do is scan the 4x6 prints, as I have no access to a 
film scanner.  Can anyone recommend a simple Web Page editor (preferably 
free or cheap) that just does simple HTML and picture embedding and doesn't 
throw tons of garbage on one's hard drive?

Peter (Phantom of the Kammermusik) Klein
Seattle, WA

Replies: Reply from John Hudson <xyyc@home.com> (Re: [Leica] Stalking the concert hall)
Reply from "Simon Lamb" <simon@sclamb.com> (Re: [Leica] Stalking the concert hall)