Re: [Leica] A sudden taboo ?(was: Codispoti for Fuhrer)

[Alan Ball <AlanBall@csi.com>]

Ted Grant wrote:
> ....<CUT>....
> So, come on guys knock off this what was then and what is now and get on
> with talking sanely about what we all love best in camera gear, the
> Leica whatever model or lens that might be.

Hi Ted,
There are basic methodologies to be applied between civilized persons in
order to discuss disputed historical facts. Before anything, these
include the reference to precise sources and exclude unfounded clear cut
judgements. These elementary precautions have not been applied here, and
those who have not applied them launched revolted responses. These
exchanges should now be ended.

I, as Leica user, have interest in both the historical facts and the
current lawsuits. 

Judging by what I have read on this list during the 8 months I have
subscribed to it, references to the history of Leitz and Leica are
abundant. This interest for history is one of the most common
differenciators between a Leica user and users of other consumer
products. It pops up whenever a reference is made to the evolution of a
lens construction or events surrounding major pictures shot by Leica
photographers. These historical references do not limit themselves to
putting a date on a serial number. Most of these threads have been
extremely instructive for me. It also seemed legitimate up to now to
refer to corporate policies and marketing decisions of the past in order
to argue about corporate initiatives today.

So why, all of a sudden, should history become taboo. Or is that taboo
limited to, let us say, "Leitz corporate policies in the years between
1933 and 1945" ?

As I wrote in an earlier post, the current lawsuit is interesting in the
sense that it should bring an end to innuendo and hearsay when refering
to the attitudes of important German corporations during those terrible
years. It will be specifically interesting for any leicaphile wishing to
have a complete update on the history of Leitz. I am also interested in
the way the current Leica management will respond to the challenge. I
spend thousands of dollars of hard earned money with that company. I am
not indifferent to its current ethics.


Friendly regards
Alan
Brussels-Belgium

PS The LUG list archives are absolutely NOT user friendly. It is very
difficult to trace an old message. I personally have no trace of
previous discussions on the subject....