[Leica] Testing macro lenses - thoughts on methodology ?

[jnelon]

Adam,
In my mind you're dealing with two completely different ideas here:
1) The subjective result of an image under controlled conditions, which will yield whatever people see with subjective eyes in a bewildering number of final settings.
And 2) an interesting laboratory measurement which will yield objective results.

Both results should be very interesting. I tell my clients to use their own equipment (iPhone, Droid, whatever) and save money paying for a Pro, unless they're faced with 1) lighting issues (low/weird light), 2) distance requirements (need to telephoto or perhaps micro) and 3) audio. And there is always a fourth: experience getting the image. A Pro will, and you may or may not.

Just my two cents.

Jim 

James R. Nelon
Partner
WNDA Studios
O: 207.389.4676
C: 508.308.6525
E: JNelon at WNDAStudios.com
Web: https://WNDAStudios.com
Highlight Reel: https://Vimeo.com/252904552
LinkedIn: https://LinkedIn.com/in/JamesNelon


-----Original Message-----
From: LUG <lug-bounces+jnelon=nelonassociates.com at leica-users.org> On Behalf Of Adam Bridge via LUG
Sent: Monday, October 4, 2021 10:14 PM
To: Leica Users Group <lug at leica-users.org>
Cc: Adam Bridge <abridge at mac.com>
Subject: [Leica] Testing macro lenses - thoughts on methodology ?

With the release of the iPhone 13 with its macro capability I wondered how it might compare with mirrorless cameras using macro lenses.

But I’m a bit stuck trying to figure out a methodology that might be useful.

I’m thinking that I’ll only use JPG files produced by the cameras’ standard settings. Use lights for consistency. Use the best ISO for the camera. Try to frame the images the same.

Other ideas? 

I’ll be using:

Sony A7Riii (90mm macro)
Fujifilm X-T3 (80mm macro)
Leica SL2-S (using the 100mm APO R lens) iPhone 13 pro max

I could, I suppose, go the RAW route. I’d process in Capture One.

Thoughts? This is sort of a “wild hare” idea but would be fun.

I’d use a selection of small flowers in several colors.

Thanks for sharing any ideas - or just telling me this is a really bad idea.

Adam Bridge


_______________________________________________
Leica Users Group.
See http://leica-users.org/mailman/listinfo/lug for more information