[Leica] Firmware Updates

[Frank Filippone]

Let's say your assesment is correct......
Agreed that changes to the aperture can only be done at the moment of 
exposure?  The aperture ring is a physical thing, and is set before the 
snap of the shutter.

I assume you did not change the aperture yourself?  IF you did change 
the aperture ring, why would the recorded and correct shutter speed be 
the same?

The exif data was "imprinted" in the file at the time of exposure and 
recording the image to the SD Card.  Agreed?  This applies ot both the 
shutter speed and the f-stop.

The shutter speed was recorded and is the same on  the 2 images.  1/4000 
sec.  See the file for this info.

The lighting in the scene may have changed a tiny bit, but no where near 
the F1.4 to F4 ( 3 stops of 8x the amount of  light) between the 2 
images.  ( this assumes the 2 images were taken at about the same time.)

So the camera, in the act of taking the picture with perspectuve control 
ON, decided an aperture change was required.......
How did the camera change the physical dial on the lens to change the 
aperture?  What mechanism was used?  Remember that there is NO physical 
connection from the lens to the body nor electrical.  YOU manually set 
the aperture on any M or M39 lens.

Are you saying there was a 3 stop differrence in the overall lighting 
and therefore the exposure beacause the sky was slightly cropped to 
allow for the distortion correction?  Arguably, in this image, a small 
difference of a fraction of an f-stop,  Certainly not 3 stops, as 
reflected by the recorded aperture and same shutter speed.

It has nothing to do with Live View, as that is also not connected to 
the aperture ring on your lens.  It is connected to the sensor et al.

Remember that to change the aperture on any M lens (or, M39 lens ever 
made) requires a mechanical movement of a ring on the lens.  There is no 
physical connection nore electrical connection on any Leica or M39 lens.
The data in the exif file is an approxikmation of the lighting 
conditions.  It is a fact.

( Not true in brand N, C Leica S or SL, or any slr type camera,) where 
the aperture control is contained in or by the camera body, availeble to 
the camera "computer" and therefore "correctly" recorded in the exif 
data fields.

If you are still a non-believer.... see these references:

https://www.dpreview.com/forums/thread/4259039
from the M10 owners manual:  P 53  Note the word APPROXIMATE
"The camera will write an approximate aperture value to the EXIF picture 
data, which is calculated individually using the exposure metering 
system. This is done whether or not an encoded or unencoded lens or a 
non-M lens is attached via adapter, and also whether or not the lens 
type was entered in the menu"

Frank Filippone
BMWRed735i at Gmail.com

On 2/1/2021 8:13 AM, James Handsfield wrote:
> I disagree - maybe because of what I saw in Live View.  Part of the perspective control involves cropping the image, which effectively reduces the sensor area with a concomitant reduction in overall exposure.
> 
> Jim
> 
>> On Feb 1, 2021, at 1:07 PM, Frank Filippone via LUG <lug at leica-users.org> wrote:
>>
>> Two comments....
>> There is no connection from the M digi cameras to the aperture dial/ring on the lens.  None.  So as much as the exif data says something, it just is not true.  Same aperture, same as what you manually set.  Note that the shutter speed is the same for both images.  The camera will properly record the shutter speed.The aperture is a guesstimate. M8-M10 all the same.  Suspect this is a bug in the FW.
>>
> 
> 
> _______________________________________________
> Leica Users Group.
> See http://leica-users.org/mailman/listinfo/lug for more information
>