Archived posting to the Leica Users Group, 2005/02/19
[Author Prev] [Author Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Author Index] [Topic Index] [Home] [Search]Right on the money, Nathan. feli On Feb 18, 2005, at 10:02 PM, nathan.wajsman@planet.nl wrote: > As painful as Leica's current travails are for those of us who have an > attachment to the brand and the history and tradition associated with > it (and I count myself in that category), throwing German taxpayer > money at the company will not solve the problem and would anyway > contravene EU rules. There are very few cases where state aid has been > a success, in the sense of helping a company survive a temporary > problem and then stand on its own again. The only case I can think of > were the Chrysler loan guarantees in the 1980s--the company survived > and repaid the loans ahead of schedule, but they also had new > management that was prepared to do a painful restructuring and new > products that were successful in the market. In virtually every other > case state aid is just money down the drain. > > Leica is a commercial enterprise in a capitalist economy. It is the > nature of such an economy that a company that cannot make a profit > eventually goes bankrupt. The movement of manufacturing jobs to low- > cost locations has been taking place everywhere in the rich world, and > yet countries like the US, the UK, the Netherlands or Scandinavia have > managed to replace the lost jobs and have unemployment rates well into > the single digits. Countries like France, Germany, Spain, Italy, which > have a long tradition for state aid to ailing enterprises, lots of > labour market and other regulations, and general state meddling in the > economy, all have unemployment rates in double digits. There is a > connection here. And note that the low-unemployment countries include > not just the perfidious Anglo-Saxons but also Continental countries > which have maintained a welfare state and a high level of solidarity. > This is indeed the direction that the German government is taking, > with the Hartz (sp) labour market reforms as an initial step. > > Leica will survive in some form, but not as a part of a handbag > marketer--the Hermes investment has given the company nothing except > some cash to allow it to operate for a bit longer. What Leica needs is > to be bought by someone like Canon, Sony et. al., in other words a > company that is successful in the photo business and can provide Leica > with some economies of scale, access to technology that Leica needs > etc. This is how the boutique car brands like Saab and Jaguar have > survived until now. They still face difficult times, but without the > investments by GM and Ford, respectively, they would surely be gone by > now. > > Nathan > > Nathan Wajsman > Almere, Netherlands > http://www.nathanfoto.com > http://www.fotosevilla.com > Print sales: http://www.photodeluge.com > Image licensing: http://www.alamy.com/search-results.asp?qt=wajsman > > ----- Oorspronkelijk bericht ----- > Van: douglas.sharp@gmx.de > Datum: zaterdag, februari 19, 2005 1:29 am > Onderwerp: [Leica] Leica - paragraph 92 > > >> As to German companies buying Leica stock to rescue the company, >> why didn't >> they do it at the time of the Hermes transaction? >> Unfortunately, Leica is neither in the Black Forest or any other >> part of >> Bavaria or the state of Baden-W?rtemmberg, which, as high-tech >> industrialareas would be very pleased to offer state subsidies for >> an ailing company >> of Leicas reputation. The state of Hessen (where Solms and Wetzlar >> are)isjust not as rich, and help from Berlin is just as unlikely. >> The present economic situation in Germany is that hardly any >> companies are >> investing in German production sites at all, in fact if the unions >> demand a >> pay rise the management threatens to move elsewhere,usually the >> new member >> states of the European Union, or even farther afield, most of the >> telephonehotlines are already located in the UK or even India. >> Even suffering from the 14th day of a 5 day collect and return repair >> service for Fujitsu-Siemans computers located in the wilds of the >> ex-GDR, >> salaries there are around 30% lower than in the rest of Germany! and >> unemployment is running at around 20% too. >> On the cards at the moment are for example massive lay offs >> planned at >> GM-Opel(up to 10,000) Deutsche Bank (6,400 although their profits >> are the >> highest in their history), one of the largest building contractors >> Walterbauhas gone bust and the best bits have been grabbed by the >> Austrian Strabag >> concern.VW has just announced lousy figures for the last quarter >> and are >> reducing workers benefits across the board. >> At the same time CEOs salaries have risen, on average,by 240% in >> the last >> couple of years, workers salaries by 2.4%. If it wasn't verboten >> there would >> have been a national strike here ages ago. >> >> Leica has been promising "Jam tomorrow" for too long now, they >> didn't just >> miss the boat, they lost the map telling them where to find the >> water and >> were always too proud to ask the way. >> Douglas >> > > _______________________________________________ > Leica Users Group. > See http://leica-users.org/mailman/listinfo/lug for more information > > ________________________________________________________ feli2@earthlink.net 2 + 2 = 4 www.elanphotos.com