Archived posting to the Leica Users Group, 1999/01/09
[Author Prev] [Author Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Author Index] [Topic Index] [Home] [Search]Dan Post wrote: > > Mark- > The Beutler formula looks similar to the Tom Abrahamson posted- are metal > tanks de rigueur? I have been using a plastic tack for most of my stuff. > Dan > dwpost@msn.com I'm 47 and and plastic tanks were recommend for beginners (the problem is its hard to switch) or people who were severely challenged in the coordination department. I think those days they were also thought to have contamination problems. I've taught quite a few people how to load metal reels and none of them found it insurmountable, Now there is Plastic with a capital P with great systems that will also do your sheet film and your prints, spin with a motor, hold little shot glasses of chemical pre heated all in a row. They require an incredibly economical amount of chemical for prints but more for film than metal. I had some experience with the Dev Tec system doing 8 by 10 Kodak direct positive (directly from slides) in a Portland Community College in '76. But I would not dream of having a motor spin my film continuously but if I ever start really liking TMax which eats Hypo I would get a motor to help agitate the Hypo as something has to help. There would seem to be people on this forum who have actually switched from metal to Jobo systems and I can't speak from experience on it. Myself and the pros I know wouldn't touch it. How much of that is chance I don't know. In the late '60s I read a Bill Pearce article in pop photo about loading your film back to back; that is two rolls back to back on one reel. It sounded dumb but at one point I tried it and have been doing it for twenty years. I have two metal 64 once tanks which hold 8 35mm reels each. In a tank with the film rolled back to back I (or my assistant) have often developed 16 rolls at a time. I'm talking thousands of rolls of film from twenty something years. This you can not do with plastic tanks to my knowledge unless you have a system as big as a room. With film the plastic tanks need more chemical, a metal tank needs 8 ounces per reel, my guess that the plastic needs 12 ounces. I forgot to mention that you could not go back to back with a plastic reel. If Xtol works out I'm under the impression that it wont work back to back. But why switch if it ain't broke? I just remembered I may go find a plastic tank and adjustable reel to develop 127 film (40by40) for my new Rollei Baby I'm planning for the near future. But I don't want to go off topic with talk of Rollei's and babies. Mark Rabiner de rigueur