Archived posting to the Leica Users Group, 2005/08/25

[Author Prev] [Author Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Author Index] [Topic Index] [Home] [Search]

Subject: [Leica] Elmarit 28mm (used) or Zeiss 28mm for M?
From: leicanikon at earthlink.net (Stephen Gandy)
Date: Thu Aug 25 12:43:26 2005
References: <8DFFA731-5BC1-493B-B6AB-92D9053539CF@mindspring.com> <430CB4D7.3000608@wanadoo.nl> <41B5BE67-1AC3-4EDF-BE38-0004D88ECA9A@mindspring.com> <6.2.1.2.2.20050825105327.03215ad8@pop.med.cornell.edu> <6.2.1.2.2.20050825171542.03c6ab30@mail.screengang.com> <6.2.1.2.2.20050825114451.00c2c8b0@pop.med.cornell.edu> <6.2.1.2.2.20050825185557.05329780@mail.screengang.com>

Zeiss took dead aim at the Leica lens line in an effort to produce better 
than
Leica M lenses.  Unlike Leica, Zeiss has plenty of money to put into R&D.
Foolishly in my view,  Zeiss lauded their efforts to the point of incredulity
by announcing in the ZM brochure the "best" lenses for Leica mount.

However if your corporate identity had spent 80 years in the shadow of one of
your  ex-exployees (Barnack), you might be a bit antsy for pay back too.

Putting aside the issue of the "Leica Look" vs the "Zeiss Look,"  I think it 
is
very safe bet Zeiss ZM are very very close to Leica's current lens M lineup.
In some cases, Zeiss has apparently exceeded Leica, but the time needs to 
tell
with more user results.  Tom A find his 50/2 Zeiss Planar to be better than 
the
current 50/2 Summicron in the close focusing range.  The 25/2.8 Zeiss is also
reputed to be hands down better than Leica's 24 Aspherical.   The new Zeiss
finders are also better than any Leica 21, 25, or 28 finder -- better than 
even
the previously best Voigtlander finders (also made by Cosina).

in short, if the new ZM 28/2.8 Biogon is not the full equal of the current 
28/2
Leica lens, it is very very close, and better than used versions of previous
Leica M 28 designs.

Stephen




Replies: Reply from jdos2 at mindspring.com (Jeff Sumner) ([Leica] Elmarit 28mm (used) or Zeiss 28mm for M?)
In reply to: Message from jdos2 at mindspring.com (Jeff Sumner) ([Leica] Elmarit 28mm (used) or Zeiss 28mm for M?)
Message from michiel.fokkema at wanadoo.nl (Michiel Fokkema) ([Leica] Elmarit 28mm (used) or Zeiss 28mm for M?)
Message from jdos2 at mindspring.com (Jeff Sumner) ([Leica] Elmarit 28mm (used) or Zeiss 28mm for M?)
Message from chs2018 at med.cornell.edu (Chris Saganich) ([Leica] Elmarit 28mm (used) or Zeiss 28mm for M?)
Message from rangefinder at screengang.com (Didier Ludwig) ([Leica] Elmarit 28mm (used) or Zeiss 28mm for M?)
Message from chs2018 at med.cornell.edu (Chris Saganich) ([Leica] Elmarit 28mm (used) or Zeiss 28mm for M?)
Message from rangefinder at screengang.com (Didier Ludwig) ([Leica] Elmarit 28mm (used) or Zeiss 28mm for M?)