Archived posting to the Leica Users Group, 2006/02/19

[Author Prev] [Author Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Author Index] [Topic Index] [Home] [Search]

Subject: [Leica] silver vs pixels
From: red735i at earthlink.net (Frank Filippone)
Date: Sun Feb 19 19:28:02 2006

Since you asked......

I have never seen a B+W digital print that I could not identify as such.  I
can see pixelation, jaggies, moire patterns, banding, and almost anything
else when I look at digital B+W.  I simply am very sensitive to the optical
effects of digitization.  The form of scientific inspection that I view
with, you may not consider fair, and the same digital print  may not bother
you, or the guy next to you, or even his neighbor, but it bothers me.  And I
can not get over the artifacts that I see.  BTW, do you know where the
additional pixels come from on a digital print?  I don;t....   I do know
that on a analog print, WYSIWYG.  Nothing is invented, fractaled,
interpolated, blended, JPG'd, compresed and decompressed, or otherwise
created by some algorithim... If it ain;t on the film, it ain't on the
print.

Not to say that I am the ultimate analog printer, because I am just a
novice....but it is MY work.  No programmer had any thing to do with it.  I
make the decisions....

As long as there is analog film, analog paper, and a darkrrom, I am sold on
analog.   It is smoother, it is archival ( historically proven, not some
theoretical BS produced by the "scientific" tests of the manufacturer), it
is better to my eye.

I do not suggest that you will agree, but at least allow that some of us are
a bit fussier or maybe just fussy people, and that digital is not our
cuppa....

Back to analog photography.... or should we break up this list into 2....
analog and digital?

as in..... Leica SIlver and Leica Bits?  My personal vote......but, then
again, I am not King......


Frank Filippone, telling it like he sees it......
red735i@earthlink.net

 yet this begs the question of why you don't love the digital
prints.

Jonathan



Replies: Reply from firkin at gexrp01.ncable.net.au (firkin) ([Leica] Re: silver vs pixels)
Reply from red735i at earthlink.net (Frank Filippone) ([Leica] silver vs pixels)
Reply from jonathan at openhealth.org (Jonathan Borden) ([Leica] silver vs pixels)
In reply to: Message from jonathan at openhealth.org (Jonathan Borden) ([Leica] silver vs pixels)