Archived posting to the Leica Users Group, 2001/01/23[Author Prev] [Author Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Author Index] [Topic Index] [Home] [Search]
On my PAW pages, I have a link for comments sent directly to me. My photography skills need all the help they can get. I will happily receive that help from members of this list. (an honest appraisal, constructive criticism with suggestions for how the image could have been improved) How about this... Praise is public, while the Bad and Ugly comments sneak into my e-mail account under cover of darkness. C.R. Marshall firstname.lastname@example.org >Ted Grant wrote: >Subject: [Leica] More PAW's question re comments asked for. > >If you'd like comments, whether you'd like to have an honest appraisal >(i.e., constructive criticism with suggestions for how the image could have >been improved) as well as praise >Whether you'd like those comments to come to you personally or as a LUG post >where everyone might learn from the comment >Lately I've looked at a lot of pictures posted by all of you. And though >I've seen many excellent images, I've seen a number which could have been >improved by a simple tweaking. In other words, do you want this to be a >learning activity as well as showing your stuff? > >Critiquing is a great way to learn. But one has to be ready for the good, >bad and the ugly comments! This means telling someone how they could have >improved the image as well as telling them what was good about it.