Archived posting to the Leica Users Group, 1998/04/11
[Author Prev] [Author Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Author Index] [Topic Index] [Home] [Search]Thanks to Donal and Eric for their replies on photo editing. I really appreciated Eric's Kuykendall quote and wish it were a widespread disposition among editors. I can't help but wonder though whether Donal's vision is closer to a teacher-pupil relationship rather than a mutually professional one. The only observation I'd like to make regarding the skills he attributes to great editors is that those very same skills are also possessed by many of the great photographers those editors are fortunate enough to work with. For every editor who's inspired me there have been ten photographers (or writers, for that matter) who've inspired me more. And it seems to me that star-struck photographers are more often impressed by the publication and/or prestige associated with that particular editor rather than anything meaningful. Yes, there are some really great editors out there, and I've had one or two (unfortunately) short but very sweet experiences working with them. I think the most inspiring editor I've encountered, coming from my limited and dearly missed freelancing days, was Colin Jacobson. It might have been my mistaken impression (it's probably impossible to micro-manage a California photographer from London), but his gracious nature and trust that I'd do my best inspired and drove me more than any others have. I'd pitch an idea. He'd get back to me and say "how long do you need?" I'd say four or five days. He'd say "OK, give a call when you're done, right?" There was of course more to most of the exchanges than that, but to this day I wish I would have done better work for him. Dave