Archived posting to the Leica Users Group, 1998/04/01

[Author Prev] [Author Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Author Index] [Topic Index] [Home] [Search]

Subject: [Leica] Recent List Issues
From: Peter Goldberg <peterg@martinhamblin.com>
Date: Wed, 01 Apr 1998 13:05:29 -0500

Cutting from the new BJP Newsletter:  two items speak for themselves.

Peterg



Dear Friends,

Welcome to this week's Professional Photographers Newsletter.

The renowned Henri Cartier-Bresson recently gave a self- depracatory
four-letter response on TV to the query about how he feels when
described
as the century's greatest photographer. A still more pointed lesson in
humility was given when he criticised those who go around declaring 'I
am
an artist.' His view, significantly, seems to be shared by many
photographers who by general consent have every right to so describe
themselves.

One of those who has rejected the unsought 'artist' title declares that
only the public interested in a medium had the 'yea' or 'nay' over a
practitioner's status -  and then only after due passage of time.
But it can be argued that photography, a mere infant among the visual
arts,
whose history spans millennia, is in one respect a special case.

If you accept that public or private funding is a good thing (and some
don't) then the perception of a photographer as an artist is essential.
In
art history terms a mere tiny tot, photography needs nurturing. If the
price is a little self-inflation, terminologically, then so be it.
Somewhat
similar in political advisability is the collector market in
photographic
equipment. Certainly there is a positive aspect to owning an original
print
made by a time-proven master. But working photographers tend to have a
sense of unease about the high prices reached for obsolete or
semi-obsolete
cameras.

On the other hand, they do promote a public respect for the material
status
of photography overall. So it may be politically correct to uphold
self-expressive photographers as artists willy nilly and their old tools
as
priceless gems. Don't let's fool ourselves, though.

Enjoy this week's issue...

Darron Hartas,
online editor
*PPN is E-mailed to over 2,000 subscribers weekly*
- ----------------------------------------------------------------
This week's printed BJP is out 1 April. View contents at:
<http://www.bjphoto.co.uk/thisweek.html>