Archived posting to the Leica Users Group, 1998/03/19

[Author Prev] [Author Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Author Index] [Topic Index] [Home] [Search]

Subject: Re: [Leica] Velvia vs. Provia - what's the verdict?
From: Five Senses Productions <fls@5senses.com>
Date: Thu, 19 Mar 1998 09:07:20 -0800

Yes, Astia is my favorite people film by Fuji.  Skin tones are very
accurate and grain is very fine for a 100 speed film.  Rating at 80
is a nice touch.

At 03:16 PM 3/18/98 -0800, Gary Todoroff wrote:
>Gruess Gott Dieter!
>
>Sorry to hear about bad weather there in the Neckar valley. But spring
>along the river is certainly worth the wait. For some great people shots in
>the Marktplatz or at the punt races, try Fuji's Astia (100 ASA). 
>
>I like Velvia for the green, green landscapes here on the Northcoast of
>California. However, I tried some Astia a while back with 50mm Summicron
>and 90mm Tele-Elmarit M lenses. Skin tones and shadow detail were
>beautiful, with none of the tendency towards reddish cheeks that Velvia
>sometimes gives. I was really pleased with the results, and the projected
>images drew some nice compliments at the local camera club. As a totally
>subjective comment, there seems to be a special skin-tone glow to Astia
>that mixes really well with sharp Leica optics. Anyone else been using
>Astia? I don't have any experience with Provia. 
>
>BTW, speaking of the Tuebingen Marktplatz, the last Viewfinder issue has
>one of my black & white photos of a street vendor taken there in 1968.
>Actually the picture is kind of an ugly orange and white. It was submitted
>as a slide at LHSA Charlotte.  I had copied the print to slide with
>photoflood lighting, giving an interesting sepia-like tone that projected
>fairly well. But it sure printed as a weird shade. 
>
>Dieter, did you ever decide on which M camera to get? Greet the owner of
>Foto-Schnell there in Tuebingen for me. The 28mm Elmarit that I bought
>there is still in great shape 30 years later.
>
>Gary Todoroff
>----------
>> From: Dieter Stoll <
>> Hi all,
>> anyone have comments on these two fine reversal films (other than Velvia
>> being 50 and Provia 100 ASA)? I haven't had too much of a chance to try
>> either with my new Leica gear, weather just plain S*CKS around here....
>Any
>> comments welcome (like, am I wasting my money and would Sensia which
>costs
>> about half the price do just as well).
>> 
>> Dieter Stoll                  D-72127 Kusterdingen, Germany
>> dstoll@tuebingen.netsurf.de   Home fax: +49-7071-368520
> 


Francesco Sanfilippo,
Five Senses Productions
webmaster@5senses.com


http://www.5senses.com/