Archived posting to the Leica Users Group, 1997/09/13
[Author Prev] [Author Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Author Index] [Topic Index] [Home] [Search]In einer eMail vom 13.09.1997 22:43:07, schreiben Sie: >At 02:31 PM 9/13/97 -0400, Alf wrote: >>I'm quite astonished on your informations, since Erwin Puts writes on his >>site/-s: >> >>"The modern Noctilux 1:1,0/50mm (11821) shows how performance has been >>boosted since 1980. It is in all respects a better lens than the famous >>Noctilux 1,2/50mm, the one with the two aspherical surfaces and much sought >>after by the collectors, who unfortunately hardley ever take pictures." >> >>And, you can't say, that Erwin Puts might be superficial or risky in his >>statements. He confirmed his results in a recent email to me, additionally. > > >This is not the first occasion on which Erwin and I have disagreed. He is >thorough and knowledgeable. I talk to a lot of folks. The result is a >healthy exchange of views. > >Marc > On the other hand, the information you cited is second source and hear-say, while his information results from his own tests. Do you have some experiences yourself, which might support the judgement of both your (professional) friends ? Alf