Archived posting to the Leica Users Group, 1997/01/02
[Author Prev] [Author Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Author Index] [Topic Index] [Home] [Search]"Legendary" M shutter reliability is just that--a Legend which is not fact. Before hoisting me by my cassettes, hear me out. The M shutter is a sophisticated, precision piece of equipment. If used and exercised regularly and given a CLA when needed, the shutter will last a lifetime--or several lifetimes. The problem is that in the real world, cameras often sit for years without attention or used or years without a CLA. Either of these scenarios does not bode well for the M shutter. The slow speeds stop working. Very long shutter speeds or hung shutters at 1 sec are VERY VERY VERY common. If you watch an experienced dealer examine an M, the first thing normally checked is the 1 sec speed because it goes out so often. The 2nd most common problem is bad high speeds. Occasionally, but not often like on the old screw mounts, the curtains themselves need replacement. About 90 % of the time when I am buying an M3/2/4 from the original owner, the shutter hangs up on the slow speeds and needs a CLA. In contrast, Nikon F's bought from the original owners very seldom need any shutter work. Yes, the M shutter is a great design, but it is comparatively high maintenance. What's better? A truly legendary reliable shutter, the Nikon F. The famous repairman Marty Forscher called it a "hockey puck" for good reason. To date, it is probably the most reliable 35mm shutter produced. How could the M shutter be improved? Obviously the shutter curtains themselves. Cloth is not the most durable design. Nikon started used Titanium in 1959. They may get worn, but they never seem to wear out. The shutter speed range could be extended too. Nikon had a 10 sec to 1/2000 range back in 1970 with the F2. I can think of no reason other than cost savings and stubbornness that Leica does not extend the M6 shutter speeds. Stephen Gandy